Your free quote may earn us a commission, but ranking is strictly performance-based.
First Premier Home Warranty: REPORT
①
First Premier Home Warranty
Overall Score
9.6
Editor's Choice
Company Details
2918 Avenue R, Brooklyn, NY 11229
Years in Business: 5
Pros
Standout speed: Many claims assigned and paid the same day.
Helpful reps: Clear answers, quick callbacks, real issue resolution.
High value: $35–$45/mo, $60 service fee; broad 49‑state coverage with useful add‑ons.
Cons
Claims: Defined limits (rust/ pre‑existing/safety); cash‑outs may be lower.
Scheduling: Parts & local techs can affect speed—using your contractor can help.
Admin: Refunds/cancellations can take time; email your request to speed things up.
Service Fee | $60 |
Monthly Fee | $35–$45 |
States Covered | 49 |
*Excludes California
Coverage Checklist
Item | Offered? | Limit |
|---|---|---|
HVAC | ✅ Yes | $1,500 Annually |
Electrical | ✅ Yes | $1,500 Annually |
Plumbing | ✅ Yes | $1,500 Annually |
Appliance | ✅ Yes | $1,500 Annually |
Electronics | ✅ Yes | Add on coverage |
Pool/Spa | ✅ Yes | Optional add-on |
Roof | ✅ Yes | Free with select Plans |
Features & Policies
Feature | Offered? | Details |
|---|---|---|
24/7 Claims Processing | ✅ Yes | 24/7 technician access |
Choose Your Contractor | ✅ Yes | Can choose own technician |
Workmanship Guarantee | ✅ Yes | 60-days on repairs |
Unknown Conditions | ❌ No | Not Covered |
Roof Leak Coverage | ✅ Yes | Optional add-on |
Waiting Period | ⚠️ Yes | 30 days |
Cancellation Fee | ⚠️ Yes | $75 after 30 days |
First Premier Home Warranty Review:
Our Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (9.6/10)
Founded in 2020, First Premier Home Warranty has quickly earned our #1 spot by delivering fast resolutions, clear terms, and top‑tier value across 49 states. The combination of straightforward coverage, responsive claims handling, and aggressive promotions (like $200 OFF + 2 months extra + free roof coverage) makes First Premier an easy #1 for homeowners. Connect with them by hitting "Get Quote" below.
Key Highlights of First Premier Home Warranty:
Simple and Clear Plans
First Premier simplifies its coverage into two understandable plans:
-
Premier Plan: Core systems and key kitchen appliances. This is ideal for essential coverage at a low price.
-
Premier Platinum Plan: Everything in Premier plus full HVAC (heating & A/C) and an expanded appliance suite. Add optional protections for pool/spa, roof leaks, well pump, and more to tailor coverage to your home.
✅ Affordable and Transparent Pricing
Pricing lands between $35–$45 per month with a consistent $60 service fee. This is lower than every company on our list. Paying annually can unlock additional savings, so try that option if you'd like to save some money.
✅ Responsive, 24/7 Claims
Claims are available online and by phone 24/7, which is great. First Premier’s network moves quickly too. Many approved claims are assigned and even paid the same day. Standard dispatch aims for 24–48 hours after approval.
✅ Choose-Your-Contractor Flexibility
Prefer a trusted local pro? First Premier Home Warranty allows you to choose your own technician to keep service predictable.
What to look out for:
-
Peak seasons: While they have a strong network, during weather spikes it's advisable to use your own contractor. Things get busy in peak season, so rather than using the phone to contact them, you can submit claims online with photos to speed things up.
-
State details: Vary very slightly by state. First Premier has a sample contract, so it would be a good idea to review your state’s sample contract and keep maintenance records/serials handy to streamline approval.
Bottom Line: Should You Choose First Premier Home Warranty?
Yes! First Premier is our #1 pick for fastest service, best coverage, and best overall experience: $35–$45/mo, $60 service fee, 49‑state reach (excl. CA), 24/7 claims with many same‑day assignments, choose‑your‑contractor flexibility, and a 60‑day workmanship guarantee. What more could you want? Discounts? They've got those too! They just started a promo that seems too good to be true. ($200 OFF, 2 months extra, free roof coverage). This makes it an easy #1 for us. You can get a free quote by clicking below.
Our Recommendation:
🏅 Highly Recommended (#1 Home Warranty Provider)